My record collection gets rearranged every time something big happens in my life. The Technics 1200s it all gets played on are the same pair I’ve had for years. So when I tell you there’s a novel about a man who does exactly that, you’ll understand why it got under my skin.
I don’t really do fiction. Biographies, yes. Self-help, yes. Business books, yes. But fiction isn’t really my thing. I read about a book a week, and nearly all of them are true stories. So a novel has to work hard to get a look in. High Fidelity by Nick Hornby is one of the very few novels that’s made it onto my list of books that shaped me.
It’s about a guy I could have become.
Rob and his top five
Rob runs a second-hand record shop in London. It isn’t doing well. His girlfriend has just left him. So he does what any proper music obsessive would do. He goes back through his top five break-ups of all time, to try and work out what went wrong.
Everything in Rob’s life comes in a top five. Top five records, top five side ones, track ones, top five dream jobs. He and the two lads who work in his shop argue about music like it’s life and death. If you’ve ever stood in a record shop and judged someone for what they picked up, you’ll recognise them straight away.
And then there’s the collection. Rob reorganises his records by when he bought them, so the shelves tell the story of his life. Finding a record means remembering where you were.
In many ways, that’s me. It’s a character I can seriously relate to.
There’s something about sorting through records when life shifts. You pick each one up, you remember, you decide where it goes now. Rob does it when his world falls apart. Hornby makes it funny, but he also makes it true. For a lot of music lovers, the collection works like a diary.
My first proper decks arrived for Christmas in 1987, when I was 12. Pretty much everything since has a soundtrack.
Very good at the past
There’s a line in the book that sums Rob up perfectly:
“I’m very good at the past. It’s the present I can’t understand.”
It’s funny, and it stings a bit. Rob can tell you the B-side of a single from years ago. He can’t tell you what he wants from his own life right now. He hides in his lists. The records are safe ground. People are harder.
If you love music, there’s a version of Rob in you somewhere. I know there is in me. The past is comfortable. You know how every record ends. The present doesn’t come with a tracklist.
That’s worth a moment of your time, even if you’ve never owned a record. What’s your version of the top five list? It might be old wins you keep replaying, or a job you were brilliant at ten years ago. It might be the way things used to be done. All of it is comfortable. None of it is happening now. Rob’s whole story is about a man slowly turning round to face the present.
What I love about the book is that Hornby doesn’t let Rob off the hook. He’s funny, he’s honest and he’s often a bit of an idiot. Slowly, very slowly, he starts to grow up. He keeps his records. He just stops hiding behind them quite so much.
You might have seen the film, with John Cusack. It moves the story to Chicago and it’s good fun. The book is better, and it’s very British. The shop, the banter and the sense of humour all feel like the record shops I grew up buying from in Southampton.
You don’t need to be a DJ to enjoy it. If you’ve ever made someone a mixtape and agonised over the order, it’s for you. If you’ve ever measured someone by their taste in music, it’s definitely for you.
It’s one of only a couple of novels in my free guide, 50 Books That Shaped Me, sitting among a whole shelf of memoirs.
So go on, while you’re thinking about it. What would make your top five records of all time, and what would the list say about you?




