First published 28 February 2022 on Your Best Year Starts Here with Nigel Risner.
Listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
Nigel had a nightmare a couple of weeks before we recorded this. Big presentation online, 1,000 people, and he couldn't hear a single one of them, so he did about 50 minutes asking questions into silence and reading thumbs up off the screen. A few months earlier a fire alarm at a hotel knocked out his power and internet halfway through a talk, and that one got to him for the whole session. This time he didn't beat himself up.
His point is that how you take feedback depends on the day you're having. Tell me you like my grey sweatshirt on a Monday and I'm chuffed. By Wednesday I've decided you're only saying it because you upset me last week.
I told him about a client who'd sent me the video of the first live run of their new hour-long webinar. I watched it and paused every time I had something to add, recording myself as I went. Before any of that I told them some of it might sound harsh, and that I was only saying it because I wanted the presentation to get better. Nigel calls that feedforward. Telling someone their top is awful when they're already wearing it doesn't give them anything to do.
Then I told my mate Joe Soto's coffee story. One person makes the other a coffee, it tastes a bit off, and if saying so starts a row, it probably isn't about the coffee. Nigel's version, as ever, is that it's not about the spoons.
Earlier on he'd offered THINK as an acronym for giving feedback, then wondered out loud if he'd just made it up. At the end he said people who start with "to be honest" wind him up, went to finish on his THINK model and couldn't remember it. To be honest, I told him, he does that a lot.
What stayed with me
- Check the other person is in the right place to hear it. Sometimes it's better left till tomorrow.
- Say why you're giving the feedback before you give it.
- Feedforward is about next time. Pointing out something that can't be changed now doesn't help anyone.
- If someone reacts badly to something small, it's probably not about the coffee.
If you're not gonna fire the person who's in your business or your client, you need to inspire them, and you can only inspire them with feedforward, not with feedback.
Nigel Risner
What's the real issue? Not the issue that's presenting itself.
Neil Martin




